Paul Volcker Laments

In the previous post ("Saving Capitalist Banking from Itself") we excerpted part of the first item John Mauldin¹ included in his "Outside the Box" e-mail today. The second item Mauldin included in today's e-mail was the text of a speech Paul Volcker recently gave in Toronto. The main subject of the speech was the sort of financial system Volcker envisions we'll have when the dust eventually settles. The speech isn't very long and is worth reading in full on Mauldin's site, but excerpted below is a brief passage that jumped out at me as I was reading it:

One of the saddest days of my life was when my grandson – and he's a particularly brilliant grandson – went to college. He was good at mathematics. And after he had been at college for a year or two I asked him what he wanted to do when he grew up. He said, "I want to be a financial engineer." My heart sank. Why was he going to waste his life on this profession?

A year or so ago, my daughter had seen something in the paper, some disparaging remarks I had made about financial engineering. She sent it to my grandson, who normally didn't communicate with me very much. He sent me an email, "Grandpa, don't blame it on us! We were just following the orders we were getting from our bosses." The only thing I could do was send him back an email, "I will not accept the Nuremberg excuse."

¹JohnMauldin@InvestorsInsight.com

"Saving Capitalist Banking from Itself"

In addition to his weekly newsletter, John Mauldin¹ occasionally e-mails articles written by others as part of his "Outside the Box" series. Today's "Outside the Box" e-mail included a couple of good ones (both of which can be read in full here). To keep this post from getting too long, I'll post an excerpt from the second one in a separate post. The graphic above comes from the first, "Saving Capitalist Banking from Itself", by PIMCO Managing Director Paul McCulley². McCulley starts with a recap of the basics of fractional reserve banking and continues with a description of the shadow banking system. The excerpt below is from the "bottom line" part of his essay:

The United States government now has both the tools and the will to save the private banking system, and more importantly, the real economy, from its own debt-deflationary pathologies. Not that it will be easy. But it can be done, notwithstanding the catcalls that greeted Secretary Geithner last week.

And the essential game plan is clear: use the power of the Fed, the FDIC and the Treasury to create government-sponsored shadow banks, such as the Term Asset-Backed Securities Lending Facility (the TALF) and the Public-Private Investment Fund (the P-PIF).

The formula? Take a small dollop of the Treasury's free-to-spend taxpayer money (there is still $350 billion left) to serve as the equity in a government sponsored shadow bank, and then lever the daylights out of it with loans from the Federal Reserve, funded with the printing press. That's the formula for the TALF, to provide leverage, with no recourse after a haircut, to restart the securitization markets.

The same formula applies for the P-PIF, with the addition of FDIC stop out loss protection for dodgy bank assets that private sector players might buy. With such goodies, such players, it is hoped, will be able to pay a sufficiently high price for those assets to avoid bankrupting the seller bank.

Unfortunately, Secretary Geithner hasn't laid out the precise parameters of how to mix these three ingredients, which is driving the markets up the wall. But make no mistake, these are the ingredients, along with continued direct capital infusions into banks where necessary.

¹JohnMauldin@InvestorsInsight.com

²You may recall McCulley's name from a previous post where we excerpted one of his essays, "Breaking the Paradox of Deleveraging".